A side by side comparison of Glock’s insanely reliable pistols – the Glock 17 vs Glock 19.
A next to each other examination of Glock’s madly solid guns – the Glock 17 versus Glock 19.
Choosing to get a Glock is the simple aspect. Choosing which Glock to get between the Glock 17 versus Glock 19, can be a bit trickier.
The Glock 17 and Glock 19 are two of the most well known guns available today. The two weapons are almost indistinguishable (the G19 and G17 share large numbers of precisely the same parts), which can make choosing the two extremely difficult.
We will analyze these two well known polymer-outlined guns so you can settle on a more educated choice with regards to which one is ideal for you
Is the Glock 17 or 19 Better?
The Glock 17 is answerable for starting the polymer gun upheaval and might be the most famous gun at any point created (Sorry, 1911!). There are at present more G17s being used all throughout the planet than some other handgun. The gun has seen administration with the Norwegian, Swiss, German, French, Russian, British, and Swedish Armed Forces. It is likewise the favored obligation weapon for law implementation organizations around the world.
In the United States, more G19s are sold every year than some other handgun. This is a significant achievement considering the G17 is all the more generally utilized by law authorization offices in the country. Most Glock 19s sold in the US go to the regular citizen market, with this gun being madly well known for hid convey.
It’s additionally important that the Glock 19 is the sidearm at present utilized by US Navy SEALs, MARSOC, and Army Rangers.
What makes these Glock guns so famous? Some would contend it’s essentially powerful showcasing. And keeping in mind that that might be consistent with a degree, no organization can keep up with a lot of the market for long with smart promoting efforts alone. Execution, dependability, reasonableness, and ergonomics have most certainly procured Glock’s darling status among American shooters.
Glock 17 vs Glock 19: Specs
Before we dive into the intangibles, let’s compare the technical specifications of these two handguns.
|Glock 17 (Gen 4)||Glock 19 (Gen 4)|
|Length||7.95 inches||7.28 inches|
|Height||5.47 inches||5.04 inches|
|Width||1.26 inches||5.04 inches|
|Weight||24.87 oz. (32.28 loaded)||23.63 oz. (30.16 loaded)|
|Sight Radius||6.5 inches||23.63 oz. (30.16 loaded)|
|Barrel Length||4.49 inches||4.02 inches|
|Magazine Capacity||17 standard (19, 33 available)||15 standard (17, 19, 33 available)|
The greatest contrasts between the G17 and G19 on paper is size and magazine limit. The Glock 17 has a barrel and hold that are both practically a large portion of an inch longer than the Glock 19. The G17’s more extended grasp leaves space for a somewhat longer magazine that holds an additional two cartridges of 9x19mm ammo.
Actually, the Glock 17’s more extended barrel and sight span should give it a benefit in exactness. When secured a tight clamp, the G17 improves at 25 meters than the G19.
In any case, 25 meters is a lot farther than the normal true shooting situation. At typical commitment distances, even talented shooters will be unable to see a distinction, and just in case they are permitted to take quiet, painstakingly pointed shots. Since that is probably not going to occur in a battle or self-protection circumstance, the precision contrast between the two guns essentially vanishes anyplace with the exception of perhaps the weapon range.
With somewhat more weight than the G19, the Glock 17 ought to enjoy a benefit in the force division, as well. Notwithstanding, those additional two ounces aren’t actually enough to assimilate a lot of backlash. Attachment a few numbers into a backlash mini-computer, and you’ll discover the force energy created from a G19 and a G17, both completely stacked with indistinguishable 9mm Luger ammunition, just contrasts by .25 ft/lbs.
The primary concern: Both guns produce negligible force that is genuinely simple for even backlash touchy shooters to deal with.
G19 vs. G17: Weight and Concealability
The G17 and G19 have indistinguishable trigger draw and slide activity, which means even the most natural Glock shooters will struggle differentiating these two guns in case they aren’t focusing. I’ve really shot my child’s G17 during drills thinking I was shooting my own G19. I didn’t understand I had “some unacceptable” gun until I holstered and the additional couple of ounces on my midriff warned me.
Albeit the size and haul of these two guns isn’t too unique, it’s amazing how much a large portion of an inch here and two or three ounces there can feel when you’re carrying around a weapon the entire day.
Solace and simplicity of-convey are amazingly significant in an EDC weapon. Your gun will invest undeniably more energy in its holster than it will drawing in dangers to life and appendage. In the event that your sidearm is burdening your belt or delving into delicate tissue, you may be enticed to leave it in the firearm safe instead of convey it with you.
With somewhat more minimized measurements, the G19 is marginally simpler to disguise. In case you’re worried about printing, the G19 might enjoy a minor benefit. Notwithstanding, in light of the fact that they have a similar width, in any event, for disguise, these two guns aren’t too unique.
What Pistol Has a Better Grip?
The Glock 17 is by and large .43 inches taller than the Glock 19. That implies there’s fundamentally more land on the grasp of the G17. There are a few “specialists” out there in the shooting scene that guarantee the additional hold length can be tricky for shooters with little hands. Others guarantee the more limited grasp of the G19 will be awkward for individuals with enormous hands.
By and by, I haven’t met anybody (regardless of whether with small young lady hands or enormous, bulky man paws) who can’t progress between the two guns absent a lot of fight. Indeed, even the Glock Gen5s and their absence of finger grooves have pretty ergonomic grasp plans. The grasp width is indistinguishable on the two guns, and really the width will presumably have a greater amount of an impact on your solace than length will. (Except if you’re in a real sense Sasquatch. Then, at that point what happens next is anyone’s guess.)
Despite the fact that, I can’t tell a distinction between the two when I’m shooting, it’s likely best to give each a test drive to ensure you have a similar encounter.
With two a bigger number of rounds than the G19, the Glock 17 truly will gloat around here. There are a lot of weapon proprietors who consider those two additional cartridges worth the extra size and weight.
Nonetheless, it’s important the Navy SEALs picked the G19 over the G17, choosing the greater part of a Glock 17 was not worth the additional mag limit. Since SEALs routinely experience trouble makers in their profession, those two adjusts likely will not significantly impact the normal regular citizen shooter. Remember that, except if you’re utilizing your Glock in a law implementation or military limit, you’re bound to utilize it to escape a predicament than in an extended weapon battle.
Of course, two rounds doesn’t seem like that many… until you need them.
If you’re worried about magazine capacity, you can always upgrade your G19 mags. Practicing your mag changes isn’t a bad idea, either.
Which is Best?
Similarly as with most things in the realm of guns, “best” is a lovely emotional term with regards to Glocks.
In the event that you intend to add extras (like a gag gadget, red spot, or weapon light), the lighter generally speaking load of the Glock 19 is a decent spot to begin. The heaviness of additional items can amass rapidly, and the G19 is as of now lighter than the G17 by around two ounces.
The more drawn out slide and sight span of the G17 can somewhat improve exactness when you can’t (or rather not) add extravagant machines. It can likewise be a resource on the opposition field, in case that is your game.
In the event that you intend to utilize your Glock as a disguised convey weapon, the somewhat more modest components of the G19 could play in support of yourself, particularly for more modest shooters where a strong handgun is bound to print. In any case, talking from individual experience (and as a meager outlined individual), there isn’t a lot of contrast between the two, particularly when I plan my closet around disguised convey instead of the reverse way around.
The Glock 19x
If you’re having trouble deciding between the G17 and G19, the Glock 19x may be the answer to your prayers. This “crossover” variant is Glock’s attempt to combine the best of both worlds. They took the best features of the G17 and G19 and wrapped them up into one practical polymer package.
The G19x has the G17 frame and the G19 slide. It is perfect for anyone who wants to conceal a duty-sized weapon. As a bonus, you still get those two extra rounds the G17 provides.
The G19x Specs:
- Length: 7.44 inches
- Height: 5.47 inches
- Width: 1.3 inches
- Weight: 24.83 oz. (31.39 oz loaded)
- Sight radius: 5.98 inches
- Barrel length: 4.02 inches
- Magazine capacity: 17 standard (19, 24, 31, 33 optional)
Because the Glock 17 and Glock 19 (and the Glock 19x) are so similar, determining which will work best for you can be difficult. The good news is there is so little difference, that even if you don’t choose the “right” one, you’ll still have a damn good pistol.